At the end of a meal, you may hear a sound calling you to have some more sweet treats. Surely, there is always room for desserts; therefore, the 8 best bakeries in Lancaster, Pennsylvania are recommended here to satisfy your sweet tooth. Everything from soft doughnuts, brownies, cookies, fresh baked breads, muffins, buttery croissants to delectable cakes which are mostly made from old-school recipes passed down from generations can now be tasted in this historical county.
Below is a list of 8 top-rated bakeries in Lancaster. The sheer number of pâtisseries features homey classics mixing with modern gastronomy, so breads and other treats from scratch are varied here. Don’t forget to bookmark the list and eat your way around Lancaster.
“Life is sweet – eat dessert first!” La Petite Pâtisserie, a dessert boutique that looks as wonderful as its delicacies taste, offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere for friends and family to enjoy breakfast and lunch. Try their celebrated flaky croissant with egg and cheese, extraordinary ‘patty melt’, or special ‘La Petite Heat’ once, you will leave satisfied.
The bake shop also carries a myriad of beautiful French dishes including freshly baked cookies, cupcakes, fruit tarts, meringues, millionaire bars, 18 macaron flavours, 12 styles of cake, and even Pennsylvania Amish traditional ‘Whoopie Pies’. However, all items are made to order. Planning for life’s celebrations? Custom buttercream wedding cakes, Sandwich trays, Bagel trays with cream cheese, croissant trays or boxed lunches must be ordered 7 days in advance.
Address: 621 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States
Opening Hours: 9:00 AM – 4:30 PM, Sunday 9:00 AM – 3:00 PM, Tuesday 9:00 AM – 1:00 PM, Monday Closed
Website: La Petite Pâtisserie | Facebook | Instagram
“Bagels, Baked Goods & Good Vibes” are daily served at one of the real farm-to-table bakeries in Lancaster, Wish You Well Bakery. Wish you were here, if you are a big fan of bagels because each morning, their whole wheat bagels in classical New York style are hand-rolled, boiled, and hearth-baked from scratch. A variety of bagels is seemingly endless: plain, sesame, everything, za’ atar, and pizza bagels.
All baked buttery goods are also made in-house using local organic ingredients and a meticulous technique to present special and nostalgic pastries monthly. For instance, in October, pumpkins, a symbol of Halloween, are adapted in various treats such as Pumpkin Coffee Cakes with Brown Butter Streusel. This is why people who want to taste the difference shouldn’t miss one of the best bakeries in Lancaster.
Experience a truly ‘sweet life’ here at a full-service bakery located in exquisite historic downtown. All kinds of Italian confections are available at La Dolce Vita Courthouse Bakery, a family-run business specialising in traditional Italian sandwiches, salads, butter cookies, and cakes. The highlight is a homemade bun and bread roll such as a seasonal Irish Soda, French, Italian and many other types.
Whether you are looking for lunch or dinner, the shop will serve freshly baked products. Most Pennsylvanians love to pair their croissants or bagels with fine espresso. Accordingly, you should try this sweet way to enjoy a perfect combination. Moreover, if you are planning a party or a wedding, any cakes or foods in your imaginations could be brought to reality.
A homegrown confectionery, Torres Family Bakery is a total hit in Millersville. Mostly, traditional Puerto Rican bread and pastries are freshly made and sold. The family often uses seasonal ingredients. For example, in summer, the base of desserts is peaches. Their famous menu that you should try is a Cream Cheese Guava Sandwich. If you are craving for a sugary one, taste their Sugar Donut which is recommended by locals that is not too sweet and warm from the oven. It is noteworthy that Square One Coffee, an award-winning coffee from Lancaster is exceptional when pairing with those good baked stuff!
Address: 447 S Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States
Opening Hours: 8:00 AM – 3:00 PM, Sunday - Closed
“joie de vivre” Experience the unforgettable joy of eating at this beloved French brasserie where scrumptious food, wine, and sweet mingle. As a result, it is an ideal place to have breakfast, lunch, and dinner when you are dating or celebrating.
Their famed savoury and sweet are flawless Bouillabaisse, a classic fish soup served with spicy rouille sauce for a memorable meal, perfect buttercream macarons and croissants with crispy and smooth texture baked by a professional chef who mastered pastry from France. Not only amazing dishes to please but also the reflection of the French lifestyle to feel. Order yours as soon as possible! You will undoubtedly say “Ooh la la”
Address: 26 E King St, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States
Opening Hours: 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Friday & Saturday 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM, Sunday 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM, Monday - Closed
Website: Bistro Barberet & Bakery
Warning: extremely addictive! A home of the original homemade sticky bun, Mr. Sticky's Homemade Sticky Buns, has been serving addictive toothsome sweets for a couple of decades. Their signature menu is ‘Sticky Buns’, a perfectly baked treat with an irresistible smell and fluffy texture which are diverse including a regular one, walnuts one, and cinnamon buns with your choice of icing: maple flavoured, peanut butter, or cream cheese icing. Coffee and a different type of beverages are also provided here. However, the dine-in service is not available.
Address: 501 Greenfield Rd, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States
Opening Hours: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM, Saturday 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM, Sunday & Monday - Closed
Website: Mr. Sticky's Homemade Sticky Buns
From Italy to Lancaster, Thom's Bread Bakery is one of the finest bakeries in Lancaster. Get back to basics with an incredibly ordinary Italian loaf flavoured deeply by only using 4 ingredients: flour, water, salt, and yeast. The bake shop offers not only bread beyond terrific but also sandwiches, pizza, bagels, cookies, salads and many more for your breakfast, lunch, and dinner. It is quite hard to rate which menu is number 1 since Pennsylvanians love fresh breads, sandwiches, and pizza that come with a wide variety. So, pick one of them, and you will be impressed at all costs.
Address: 113 Butler Ave, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States
Opening Hours: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM, Saturday 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Sunday - Closed
Website: Thom's Bread Bakery | Facebook | Instagram
Central Manor Bakery & Grille is a locals’ favourite tiny sweet shop. It has a little of something for every type of sweet tooth. Whether you visit in the morning, midday or evening, hot foods and baked goods will be served. For breakfast, French toast and Home Fries is a must, whereas Chicken and Waffles is the best for lunch. Their well-known sweetmeats are apple pies, cakes, and cookies; hence, do not leave without a pastry or you will regret it!